A Genuine Arab Voice For Islamic Reform


Interviewer: Do you have a problem with religion?

Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib: Of course not. My problem is with religious coercion. That is what goes on in most Arab countries.

Amidst the endless stream of blather across the political spectrum about “reform” in the Islamic world, from the dangerously uninformed pieties of a Michael Novak (who insists upon supporting so-called reformist Muslims, that “…know these [‘freedom, individual dignity, equality under the law, and the rule of law’] flow also from Islam…”), on the right, to the deliberately deceitful characterizations of Islamic Law and history by the thrusting young auto-janissary Noah Feldman, on the left, I am constantly drawn back (seeking mental solace!) to the uncompromised, pellucid arguments for genuine reform enunciated (here, and in more detail here) by the Pakistani ex-Muslim scholar (and dear colleague), Ibn Warraq.

Now thanks once again to MEMRI, an articulate and immensely courageous Kuwaiti woman journalist, Ibtihal Al-Khatib has articulated, elegantly, in her own voice the same arguments put forth by Ibn Warraq. These are the intellectuals we and our governments in the West, and all other bastions of liberal democracy, must support openly, if Islamic societies are ever to emerge from their oppressive barbarity.

The following extracts are from an interview of Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib which aired on Al-Arabiya TV on March 14, 2008 wherein she continued to criticize Hizballah—despite receiving threatening letters, calling her a Jew, a collaborator, and an apostate—while maintaining that secularism is the only way to protect religious freedom in Arab Muslim societies.

Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib: Our mission, as journalists, is to make it clear that the principles of secularism and liberalism, which have gained a bad reputation recently in the Arab world, are not…


Interviewer: Why have they gained a bad reputation?

Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib: Because they are characterized as heretical.Interviewer: You mean that they are confronted by accusations of heresy.

Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib: Yes. Anyone who is secular is accused of being a heretic, which is absolutely untrue. Secularism is the belief in the separation of religion and state. In other words, religion belongs to God, and the state belongs to all. Every person is free to practice his religion and follow his spiritual path, but all are subject to a civil state. That way, we ensure just treatment for all, instead of Sunnis enjoying more rights than Shiites, or vice versa, and Christians having no rights whatsoever in an Islamic state.[…]I won’t say that I am either Shiite or Sunni – I declare myself to be a Kuwaiti, and that’s it. As for my spiritual path, it is between me and my Creator.

Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib: All I’m saying is that you cannot use these [core Islamic] texts to build a modern state. I say this is impossible, because there are many different ways of understanding these texts. In addition, in modern countries, there are not only Muslims. You cannot build a country on Islam alone, and exclude followers of other religions. Interviewer: So you want a state that has nothing to do with Islam?

Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib: I want a state that is not based on religion – a civil state. But one of the conditions is to protect people who want to practice their religion. Let me give you an example. The Bohra is a Muslim sect, which has recently been denied the right to have a mosque in Kuwait. Why?


Interviewer: You want to defend religious rights with secularism.

Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib: Secularism protects the rights of minorities, and all the religious rights. Of course.

Interviewer: Sometimes the rights of the majority are lost amid all the talk about the rights of the minorities.

Dr. Ibtihal Al-Khatib: How can they be lost, if you establish a civil regime that protects everybody, and tells you that just as you are free to follow your Sunni path, I am free to follow my Shiite path, and Christians and Jews have their rights too? This way we are all equal and protected by the secular regime, which treats us all without discrimination


Andrew G. Bostom is the author of The Legacy of Jihad (Prometheus, 2005) and The Legacy of Islamic Antisemitism " (Prometheus, November, 2008) You can contact Dr. Bostom at @andrewbostom.org

One response to “A Genuine Arab Voice For Islamic Reform

  1. damn she’s good-looking. She should be a poster girl for “New Islam”. She should be on every talk show. Anyone at the CNN watching?